Halkard E. Mackey, Jr.
 
Environmental & Geographic Information Systems
Integration Support Section
Westinghouse Savannah River Company
Aiken, SC 29808
 
Roles of Historical Photography in Waste Site Characterization,
Closure, and Remediation
 
ABSTRACT
Over 40,000 frames of historical vertical photography from 1938 to 1996 and over 10,000 frames of oblique photography from 1981 to 1991 of the 777-sq km Savannah River Site (SRS) in South Carolina are being reviewed, catalogued, and referenced utilizing ARCView and associated ArcInfo software. This indexing allows environmental reviews of over 450 potential waste sites on SRS to support work plans, characterization, ecological risk assessments, and closure of waste sites in a more cost-effective manner. A case history of potential waste site mapping within a former cooling-water lake is presented to demonstrate the utility of these historical photographic records of SRS.
 
 INTRODUCTION

The 777-ha SRS, formerly known as the Savannah River Plant, is located in south central South Carolina along the Savannah River on the upper Atlantic Coastal Plain of the United States. The SRS was established in the early 1950's for the production of special nuclear materials, primarily to support the nuclear weapons program of the United States. SRS has a rich history of remote sensing data and activities. From the initial phases of SRS, vertical aerial photography was used by the US Forest Service to manage timber resources on SRS. Therefore, photography is available every few years from this program from the 1950's until 1996. Document of SRS facilities and operations is included in this photography. Numerous other flights were conducted, as with the National High Altitude Program or by the Department of Energy (DOE) through the Remote Sensing Laboratory (RSL), Las Vegas, Nevada. Other documentation of past operations are in the form of low altitude, oblique photography and video acquisitions primarily by RSL. Low altitude, aerial gamma over flights, repeated every 5 to 10 years after 1974, provide valuable information on areas of low-level contamination of man-made radioactive on SRS and represent a reasonable alternative for surveying large areas effectively and efficiently. More recently, specialized airborne remote sensing scanners (Multispectral Scanners (MSS)) provide coverage of areas of interest, such as SRS wetlands. Satellite data (SPOT and Thematic Mapper) provide synoptic views of SRS, for landuse/land cover mapping, not easily obtained with ground based surveys. As data have accumulated and technologies advanced, the remote sensing data are becoming available in digital format in Geographic Information Systems (GIS), instead of hard copy format. As SRS moves to remediation activities, these historical data become a portion of the baseline for waste site characterization and evaluation to permit faster and more efficient closure to occur in the future.
 

  AERIAL OBLIQUE PHOTOGRAPHY

Oblique coverage of SRS was acquired during January, 1971; June, 1974; December 1975; June, 1979; March, September, and October, 1981; August and September, 1982; March and August, 1983; March, May, and November, 1984; February, June, and August, 1985; March, April, June, and August, 1986; February, March, and June, 1987; March, 1988; April, 1990; May and June 1991; and April, 1994. The 1982, 1983, and 1984 flights are summarized in Meibaum (1984a, 1985a). The oblique photography provide SRS with a catalogue of major operating areas and construction activities, as well as areas of interest such as waste sites, cooling lakes, and forestry test plots. In the 1980's and early 1990's, numerous waste sites were photographic several times from several angles. The original negatives are stored at RSL and can be retrieved by proof book and frame number.

 

VERTICAL AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHY

 
An expansive vertical aerial photographic collection exists for SRS.  For example,  representative flight lines and photographic frame centers for a 1986 US Forest Service site-wide over flight of the SRS are shown in  Figure 1 .   Most of the photography prior to 1974 is black and white, while that after 1974 is color, either as normal color (NC) or false color infrared (FCIR). The most common altitude is 10,000 feet above ground level (AGL) and the most common scale is 1:15840. SRS was flown at 4 to 5-year intervals by the US Forest Service to assist with timber management (1955, 1956, 1966, 1973, 1974, 1979, 1982, 1986, 1989, 1992, and 1996). SRS was flown three times under the National High Altitude Photographic program (1981, 1989, and 1994). Since 1981, SRS has been flown, either in part or with almost complete coverage at a variety of altitudes and with differing film types by RSL (EG&G, 1981, 1983; Meibaum, 1984b, 1985b). Nearly site-wide coverage is available for almost every year since 1973; therefore, a photographic history of any location on SRS can be recreated.
 
 
Two sets of site-wide, vertical photography from 1938 and 1943 exist prior to establishment of SRS. These two sets provide a record of landuse on SRS prior to construction of the site (Christel, 1994) and both are available through the National Archives. Photography were taken in 1951 at 2,000 and 10,000 foot altitude, during early construction of SRS, thus details of the land cover were documented and the photography is available as a digital file (Lloyd,  et al., 1996). The 1955 and 1956, black and white photography is of fair quality and only prints have been located. Much of the photography in the 1950's and 1960's have portions of the frames near the operating areas of SRS removed from the prints and/or negatives, as part of the security practices at that time; thus, their utility for review of history of selected locations on SRS has been reduced. The construction activities of Par Pond are covered in a low and high altitude set of photography during 1958 and are especially useful for that project. The 1961 black and white coverage was flown at a higher altitude and has less utility. The 1973 and 1974, black and white coverages are of good quality. In 1971 and 1977, high altitude black and white coverage was flown by the US Airforce. Fall 1978, FCIR photography flown by the Savannah River Ecology Laboratory (SREL), University of Georgia, SRS, provides one of the best sets of early "color" photography. Another set of site-wide black and white coverage was flow in 1981  for the Soil Conservation Service for soil mapping of SRS. Photographic coverage by the US Forest Service occurred in 1979 (NC), 1982 (NC and FCIR), 1986 (NC and FCIR), 1989 (NC and FCIR), 1992 (FCIR), 1996 (NC) are valuable resources and are available from USDA-ASCS, Aerial Photography Field Office, Salt Lake City, Utah.

 
The coverages flown by EG&G (currently Bechtel Nevada) started in 1974 and are extensive, especially after 1981. These flights supported a variety of projects, mostly related to reactor operations, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and thermal and wetlands evaluation. Frequently the photography was collected in support of airborne MSS flights. For example, historical photography were used to evaluate the condition of the streams and the SRS Savannah River swamp, which received once-through, secondary  cooling water from the reactors on SRS ( Sharitz, et al., 1974a; Tinney, et al., 1986; Jensen, et al., 1993a,b). Likewise, the history of aquatic vegetation development around the shoreline of the Par Pond was documented with aerial photography (Ezra and Tinney, 1985b; Jensen and Mackey, 1991a,b; Jensen, et al., 1991c; Rea, et al., 1996). Mackey (1993) outlined the usefulness of aerial photography for the study of Carolina Bay wetlands on SRS.

 
Aerial photography has been used to develop site-wide GIS coverages for SRS. A historical wetlands map, based on pre-SRS (1943 and 1951) photography (Christel, 1994), a site-wide landuse/land cover map (Ezra and Tinney, 1985a; Ezra, 1985; Ezra, et al. 1986; Christel and Guber, 1994), and site-wide soils GIS coverage (Rogers, 1990) were developed with the aid of site-wide aerial photography. In addition, representative historical photography of SRS was incorporated into a series of image browse files to allow for quick viewing of any location on SRS over time (Bresnahan, et al., 1994; Cowen, et al., 1995; Jensen, et al., 1995, 1996). These resources will prove to be valuable in development of the history of waste sites at SRS for site characterization, evaluation, risk assessment, closure plans, and future monitoring (Airola and Kosson, 1989; Christel, 1996; Mackey, 1994; Stohr, et al., 1987; Stohr and Lunetta, 1994).

 

CASE HISTORY
MAPPING OF POTENTIAL WASTE SITES IN L LAKE

 
To demonstrate the utility of historical photography of SRS in evaluation of waste sites, an evaluation of the types and locations of potential waste sites within a former, cooling-water lake (L Lake) is summarized below. In addition to the use to vertical  photography primarily from 1984-1985, low altitude oblique photography and video was also available and was useful in verification of activities or classification of the various types of waste sites in the lake bed of L Lake, but these materials are not summarized here.

 

Background

 
L Lake was developed as a cooling-water reservoir for L Reactor on SRS. The construction of the lake along Steel Creek began in the fall of 1984 and was completed one year later in September 1985. When completed, the lake had a capacity of 31 million cubic meters and a normal pool elevation of 58 meters above mean sea level. L Reactor operated from 1985 until 1988. However, in spite of L Reactor shutdown in 1985, the lake level was maintained at normal pool level. In 1996-1997 evaluations, which could lead to   the eventual draining of L Lake, were initiated as part of potential cooling water system shutdown at SRS. Since the Steel Creek flood plain was an area of low level gamma contamination (Briese et al., 1975; Brisbin et al., 1974; Gladden et al., 1985; Jobst, 1987, 1988; Sharitz et al., 1974b) and contaminated soil and vegetation materials had been relocated during the L Lake construction activities, historical photography from 1984 through 1985 until just prior to filling of the lake were evaluated. Maps of disturbed areas such as borrow pits, upland vegetation ash pile burial sites, flood plain contaminated vegetation sites, flood plain dam soil removal and construction burial sites were produced for over 63 hectares of disturbed areas within the 400 hectares of the lake bed. In addition, a digital elevation model (DEM) was created using soft copy photogrammetry techniques, so that various L Lake draw-down scenarios   at different lake levels could be evaluated with respect to waste site exposure and remediation (Christel, 1996).

Steel Creek is one of five major streams on SRS. This stream rises on SRS and flows approximately 18 km south to the Savannah River flood  plain and Savannah River on the southern portion of SRS. Operations of P and L Reactors began in 1954 and once-through cooling-water was discharged initially from these two reactors to Steel Creek. Stream flows in Steel Creek increased from its natural flow of about 1 cubic meter per second to a maximum of 24 cubic meters per second with the secondary cooling-water effluent pumped from the Savannah River. The secondary cooling-water was released at temperatures as high as 70 degrees centigrade; thus, theses two reactors greatly influenced the hydrologic and thermal regimes of Steel Creek. The results of the increased flow in Steel Creek included inundation of the creek flood plain, erosion, and loss of the original wetland plant communities. In addition, from 1955 to 1973, approximately 284 curies of cesium-137 were released into Steel Creek. Because of a strong affinity for sediments, a majority of the released material was absorbed and/or deposited in the sediments of Steel Creek and   the adjacent SRS Savannah River flood plain (Briese, et al., 1975; Brisbin, et al. 1974; Feimster, 1992; Gladden, et al., 1985; Jobst, 1987, 1988; Shartiz, et al., 1974). Cooling-water effluent from P Reactor was diverted to Par Pond on SRS in 1963, and L Reactor was placed on standby in 1968; thus, returning Steel Creek to a more near normal flow regime. Refurbishment of L Reactor began in the early 1980's with plans  to restart the reactor in 1985. To provide thermal mitigation of cooling-water from the restart of L Reactor, L Lake was constructed by damming the middle reach of Steel Creek. With the cessation of thermal releases to Steel Creek in 1968, scrub-shrub and persistent and non-persistent emergent plant communities had colonized the Steel Creek flood plain and were in place when L Lake construction began in 1984 (Tinney   et al., 1986; Wein and McCort, 1988). The upland areas of L Lake had been managed primarily as pine stands. L Reactor was restarted in the late fall of 1985 and continued operating until it was again placed on standby in 1988.

 

L Lake Construction

 
Construction of L Lake began in the fall of 1984. L Lake was formed by damming the middle reach of Steel Creek between SRS Road B and Highway 125. The resulting 400-hectare, L Lake has a capacity of 31 million cubic meters and is 7000 meters long and 1200 meters  wide at it widest point (average 600 meters). The dam, located at the south end of the lake, is 1200 meters long. The normal pool of the lake is 58 meters above mean sea level (MSL) and the top of the main embankment of the L Lake dam is 61 meters above  MSL. Clear cuts made during construction of the lake totaled 418 hectares including 144 hectares of bottom land hardwood and shrub wetlands, 146 hectares of upland hardwood and pine forest, and 50 hectares of other areas within the lake basin (Ezra and Tinney, 1985; Tinney et al., 1986; Wein and McCort, 1988; Wein and Pierce, 1995). Timber growing above the Steel Creek flood plain was cut for commercial sale. Outside the lake basin additional areas were clear-cut for power line right-of-ways and other construction related activities (McCort et al., 1988).

 
During the construction of L Lake dam, dredged spoil from the flood plain of Steel Creek at the dam site was placed in a special waste disposal area, allowed to dry, leveled, and then covered with 1.5 meters of soil (Ziegler et al., 1985) ( Figure 2 ). Although only the upper 1.2 meters of flood plain material was considered to be radioactively contaminated, the stream bed was excavated to a depth of about 3 meters (Gladden   et al., 1989). This spoil material was estimated to contain 0.2 curies of cesium-137 and 0.02 curies of colbalt-60 (Zeigler et al., 1985). Approximately 46,400 cubic meters of spoil material were removed from the dam site. The area of this waste disposal site for the L Lake dam construction site was estimated to be about 5 hectares based on interpretation of digitized aerial photography from September 1985. This buried spoil site was flooded over when the lake was filled.

 
Trees outside of the Steel Creek flood plain were sold through commercial timber harvests. The remaining debris from the upland tree harvest and sale was pushed into piles, burned, and covered with local soil materials prior to filling of the lake. Five hundred eighty-four (584) of these ash piles were identified and mapped in aerial photography of L Lake during the construction activities ( Figure 2 ). Trees and shrubs within the flood plain itself were potentially contaminated from the radioisotopes in the flood  plain soils. Vegetation growing in the flood plain area of Steel Creek covered   by the lake was estimated to contain about 12 milli-curies of cesium -137 (Zeigler   et al., 1985). The woody vegetation in the Steel Creek flood plain was removed from the upper two-thirds of L Lake, but was left standing in the lower one-third of the flood plain immediately upstream of the coffer dam used during the construction of the L Lake  dam. The vegetation removed from the flood plain was buried in an estimated one hundred fifty-four (154) sites adjacent to the Steel Creek flood plain and covered with 1 to 2 meters of local soil material prior to the filling of the lake ( Figure 2 ).
 
 

 
Before L Lake was filled, 35 artificial reefs including 3 log reefs, 7 brush reefs, 12 tire reefs, 12 concrete block reefs, and 1 floating tire breakwater were constructed. The reefs were constructed to provide habitat diversity and structure in the lake before an aquatic plant community was established (Gladden et al., 1989; Wein and Pierce, 1995). These artificial structures are evident in the aerial photography used to map L Lake   prior to filling. The filling of L Lake began on September 15, 1985, and the lake reached its normal operating level of 58 meters above MSL on November 4, 1985 (Gladden et al., 1989). During the summer of 1986, a rip rap diversion dike and canal were constructed in the northern end of L  Lake just south of SRS Road B to more effectively use the cooling capacity of the lake. Changes in L Lake caused by the construction of this  dike  and canal are not included here.

 

Historical Photography of L Lake Construction Activities

 
A review of historical photography available from RSL indicated that several aerial acquisitions of Steel Creek had occurred during 1984-1985. Pre-construction flights show the presence of test drillings near the future L Lake dam site and an existing borrow pit in the upper portion of the future (March 31, April 1, June 18, and September 19, 1984). Archeological survey pits are also visible in this 1984 photography. Construction began in the fall of 1984. Aerial photography of the L Lake construction activities  was acquired on the following dates: April 17, April 25, May 14, May 18-19, June 21, and September 6, 1985 (Table1). Based on the information in the photography, material appears to have been removed from within the Steel Creek flood plain at the L Lake dam construction site and deposited in a large pit north of the dam site and east of the Steel Creek flood plain ( Figure 2 ). Aerial gamma surveys conducted in August 13-23, 1985, of the Steel Creek flood plain show no cesium-137 activity in close  proximity to the dam construction site, nor in the area of the disposal site (Jobst, 1988). Commercial timber harvesting was wide spread   throughout the upland areas (non-flood plain areas of the future lakebed). Following the timber harvest, the remaining debris was placed in piles and burned. Debris and ash piles are visible in the aerial photography. The ash piles, which are characteristically oval-shaped, were covered with local soil materials and numbered to several hundred (Table 3 and  Figure 2 ).

 
The time sequence of photography shows that after the upland areas were harvested, the flood plain was cleared of timber and a series of disturbances or pits occurred lateral to or within the flood plain. This activity began in the northern portion of the lakebed and continued southward. These features or pits appear at irregular intervals and are likely the locations of contaminated materials removed from the flood plain. They are less well-defined in shape and appear to "cast a shadow," which indicates that they are 'mound-like." It is estimated that there are more than 150 of these "mounds" or pit burials. Some of these pits may not have been used, especially in the lower one-third of the lake where much of the flood  plain vegetation was still standing as observed in the last vertical aerial photography which was taken on September 6, 1985. The filling of L Lake began on September 15, 1985. Aerial photography acquired after September 1985 shows the lake at full pool.

 
In addition to the vertical photography, ground photography of the construction activities were reviewed from SRS achieves and records taken primarily by the COE during the construction of L Lake. Low altitude video tapes (March and October 1984) and oblique photography (March and September, 1984, and March and August, 1985) taken from helicopter over flights of the lake during the construction activities was also reviewed. These additional sources of information were especially valuable in determining the sequence  of changes associated with the construction of L Lake and in interpretation of the changes which occurred in the lakebed.

 

Soft Copy Photogrammetry of L Lake
Ortho-Photographic Processing

 
To map the L Lake basin, vertical aerial photography acquired on September 9, 1985, nine days before filling of the lake began, was selected as the base imagery (Christel, 1996). Most of the construction and clearing activities were either completed or nearly complete at this time, except for the final construction of the L Lake dam itself. The timeliness and scale (1:13900) (Table 1) provided the most comprehensive visual record available for the lake and; therefore, was used for the digital mapping effort described below.

 
The series of photographs used to support the digital ortho-photographic mapping of L Lake waste sites included frames 92 through 99 of EG&G file or proof book roll number 5108. The photography was acquired between 9:45 and 9:49 am on September 9, 1985, with a north heading and an altitude above ground level of 7,000 feet. The photographic system was a Wild Heerburg RC-10, large format, aerial camera equipped with a 153-millimeter lens and Aerocolor 2445 film. The imagery was cloud free, and contains well-defined shadows due to the low sun angle from the  early morning flight. The original spool film was scanned at 50 microns on a Howtek flatbed scanner to yield a resolution of one-meter for the  mapping. The binary digital photographs were converted to .img files, rotated, and reviewed using ERDAS Imagine, Version 8.2, image processing software (ERDAS, 1995). The images were rotated so that north (the direction of the flight line) was to the right. This rotation gave the best parallax  for the correction function employed during the ortho-rectification process. Based predominantly on overlap and scan quality, frames 92, 94, 96, 97, 98, and 99 were selected and imported into SoftPlotter ™ Version 1.6, Vision International's soft copy ortho-photogrammetric package (Vision International, Inc., 1996). For best results from SoftPlotter, camera calibration information is required. This information was obtained from Leica  NA, Inc. The camera calibration certificate lists import lens information including the calibration  focal length, the principal point of symmetry, and the radial distortion away from the principal point of symmetry. The manufacturer's fiducial mark locations with respect to the focal center of the camera frame are also given. All of these values are used  by the SoftPlotter Interior Orientation routine to calculate the mathematical  relationships between the camera lens and the lens and the ground.

 

Table 1. Vertical Aerial Photography Used for Mapping Construction Activities
and Producing the Digital Elevation Model of L Lake
 
Proof Frame Date Altitude as Scale Film
Book Number (M/D/Year) Feet Above  Type
Number* Ground Level
4644 006 03/31/84 17000 1:34000 Color Infrared
4655 006 03/31/84 17000 1:34000 Color
4655 161-164 04/01/84 8000 1:15700 Color
4755 174,194 06/18/84 10000 1:19900 Color
4840 16-22 09/19/84 20000 1:39200 Color
4840 63-86 09/19/84 8000 1:7960 Color
4966 62-63 04/17/85 20000 1:41400 Color
4966 73 04/17/85 6000 1:11900 Color
4973 105-112 04/25/85 4000 1:7960 Color
4991 10-19 05/14/85 6000 1:11900 Color
4992 10-19 05/14/85 6000 1:11900 Color Infrared
4933 83-104 05/18/85 10000 1:19900 Color
4994 84-104 05/18/85 10000 1:19900 Color Infrared
4997 66-73 05/19/85 7000 1:13900 Color
4998 66-73 05/19/85 7000 1:13900 Color Infrared
5033 75-81 06/21/85 6000 1:11900 Color
5033 82 06/21/85 17000 1:33800 Color
5108 88 09/06/85 20000 1:39200 Color
5108 92-100 09/06/85 7000 1:13900 Color
                                                *Source of Photography is RSL Archieves.
 
 
In SoftPlotter, the "L Lake Project" was defined, the camera type and values were entered, and the six images were imported. Interior orientation was performed and a maximum acceptable root mean square error (RMSE) was set to the equivalent of one meter or 1.4 pixels in the image data. Once information pertaining to the camera-lens relationship was determined, ground control points (GCP) were defined in order to calculate the photographic/ground relationship. GCPs came from a variety of sources (Table 2) for  the triangulation portion of the mapping effort. Results of the triangulation process are dependent on several user-defined constraints. These parameters are selected based on knowledge of the factors  affecting the photographic acquisition and film quality. Rigid constraints can be employed when optimum conditions, such as the following are met: known flying height, good film quality, minor distortions in the photography due to flight parameters, gentle topography, and adequate ground control. Optimum conditions were met with the L Lake project, so rigid constraints were used. Based upon image RMSE residual for x, y, and z  values, the triangulation process yielded acceptable results.

 
Epipolar re-sampling of the triangulated overlapping imagery was performed using the proprietary algorithms provided in the Stereo Tool module in SoftPlotter. This process resulted in five stereo-pairs of images that were oriented such that y-parallax was  removed  and x-parallax was interpreted as differences in elevation. The stereo-pairs were displayed to quality check the apparent success of the re-sampling before the digital elevation model (DEM) was generated.

 
Table 2. Control Point Information
 
 

Type Number Source
Horizontal 13 Differential GPS*
Vertical 7 USGS Quadrangles**
Tie Points 6 Frame Feature
 

*Global Position System provided by Westinghouse Savannah
River Company Personnel, R. S. Riley

**Girard NW and Girard NE 7.5minute series (USGS,1964)
 

   DEM Generation

 

The five stereo-pairs were used as the sources for the DEM. Collection parameters were defined with a ground spacing of one meter, and a DEM was produced for each stereo-pair. This was an iterative process and the most time intensive, because the software provides  ample methods for improving posting results through the use of break-lines and other site-specific point and surface adjustments. For L Lake, the forest edge was the biggest consideration during the editing process. Special attention was given to those  areas directly affecting the shoreline elevations. When the DEMs for each stereo-pair were completed, a mosaic image was produced (ERDAS, 1995). Based on known and map-measured check points, elevation errors of the  DEM ranged from 0.037 to 1.70 meters. Horizontal accuracy was less than 10 meters.

 

Digital Ortho-Photography Generation

 
Ortho-photographs were derived from the five images and the DEM using a defined ground spacing of one meter in the Ortho Tool module in SoftPlotter (Vision International, Inc., 1996). As with the DEMs, the ortho-photography were merged using the mosaic routine in Imagine 8.2 (ERDAS, 1995). This image and the DEM were subsequently used to generate raster products and ArcInfo coverages (Esri, 1996) to determine the location, extent, and type of disturbances that were visible in the lakebed on September 6, 1985, just prior to the initial fill date of the lake nine days later.

 

Digital Ortho-Photographic Interpretation Results

 
The features (feature cover types) within the lakebed were grouped into seven categories based on the preliminary review of the source photography (Table 3). The temporal sequence of the aerial (Table 1) and ground photography indicate that these feature types were the primary areas used for the removal, transport, dumping, disposal, covering, and subsequent containment of the majority of material relocated during the construction of L Lake. Thus, two areas, totaling 5.87 hectares, were identified as potentially  receiving contaminated soil materials removed from the flood plain of Steel Creek during the construction of the L Lake dam ( Figure 2 ). Borrow pits and similar areas of disturbance consisted of fifteen   areas totaling 29.04 hectares. One hundred fifty-four  areas, totaling 6.42 hectares, were identified as potential vegetation waste piles were materials were removed from the contaminated Steel Creek flood plain. These vegetation waste piles are typically adjacent to the flood plain or are within the Steel Creek flood plain. Five hundred eighty-four ash piles account for 21.41 hectares in the lakebed. As stated earlier, these ash piles   resulted from burning of piles of debris remaining from the commercial sales of upland vegetation and the subsequent covering   of the ash piles with local materials using bulldozers. Table 3 also lists other types of features and structures constructed in L Lake, i.e., fish habitat structures.

 
 

Table 3. Summary of Disturbances in L Lake Prior to Filling in September, 1985
 
 
Disturbance Type Number of Occurrences  Mean Size (hectares) Total Area (hectares)
Dam Soil Burial Sites 2 2.94 5.87
Vegetation Burial Sites 154 0.04 6.42
Upland Ash Piles 584 0.04 21.41
Borrow Pits and Similar Areas 15 1.94 29.04
Debris Piles 13 0.04 0.46
Fish or habitat Structures 27 0.01 0.21
Total Area 63.41
 
 
SUMMARY

 
Historical aerial photography provided a powerful resource to assist in the reconstruction of the location of disturbances within a former cooling-water lake on a DOE site. The types, numbers, size, and locations, both as to coordinates and elevations could be reconstructed using ortho-photogrammertic and other digital imagery and Geographic Information System (GIS) technologies. By using the digital maps in conjunction   with the DEM for L Lake, information can be provided to support future sampling and characterization   evaluations that may be required, if the lake were to be drained and remediation and/or landscape restoration were required. Without the reconstruction of the lakebed configuration as it   existed just prior to filling in September, 1985, characterization  and remediation evaluations would be more difficult.

 
In a manner similar to that used with historical photography of L Lake, the history of many of the waste sites on SRS can be reconstructed. This reconstruction would yield information on the location, time period of use, and environmental conditions at or  near  the waste site; therefore, improving future closure activities associated with these waste sites.

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The author is most appreciative of the efforts provided by R. S. Riley in collection of field GPS data to support georegistration of the L Lake photography.  Much of the case history data for L Lake was developed by Lynne Christel of Bechtel Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada.  Cheryl Hardy of WSRC was instrumental in assisting with manuscript preparation.
 

End Note
 
This information contained in this manuscript was developed during the course of work under Contract No. DE-AC09-89SR18035 with the US Department of Energy.
 
REFERENCES

 
Airola, T. M. and D. S. Kosson. 1989. Digital Analysis of Hazardous Waste Site Aerial Photographs. Journal Water Pollution Control Federation. 61(2):180-183.
 
Bresnahan, P. J., D. J. Cowen, J. R. Jensen, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1994. "Integrating Heterogeneous Data to Develop a Large-Scale Environmental Data Atlas for Multi-Platform Users." Proceedings GIS/LIS '94 Annual Conference and Exposition, October 25-27, 1994. Phoenix, Arizona. pp. 96-104.
 
Briese, L. A., C. T. Garten, Jr., and R.R. Sharitz. 1975. "Distribution of Radiocesium in Vegetation Along a Contaminated Stream." Mineral Cycling in Southeastern Ecosystems. USAEC Symposium Series, CONF-740513. pp. 509-517.

Brisbin, I. L., Jr., R. J. Beyers, R. W. Dapson, R. A. Geiger, J. B. Gentry, J. W. Gibbons, M. H. Smith, and S. K. Woods. 1974. "Patterns of Radiocesium in the Sediments of a Stream Channel Contaminated by Production Reactor Effluents." Health Physics. 27:19-27.

Christel, L. M. 1994. Historical Wetlands Mapping and GIS Processing for the Savannah River Site Database. EGG 11265-1018. EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Christel, L. M. and A. L. Guber. 1994. Land Cover Mapping and GIS Processing for the Savannah River Site Database. EGG 11265-1016. EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Christel, L.M. 1996. Historical Aerial Photographic for Waste Unit Mapping in an Existing Lake through Digital Bathymetric Modeling. Bechtel Nevada, P.O. Box 98521, Las Vegas, NV 89193-8521

Cowen, D. J., J. R. Jensen, P. J. Bresnahan, G. Ehler, D. Graves, X. Huang, C. Wiesner, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1995. "The Design and Implementation of an Integrated Geographic Information System for Environmental Applications." Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing. 61(11):1393-1404.

EG&G. 1981. A Catalogue of Vertical Aerial Imagery of the United States Department of Energy's Savannah River Plant and Surrounding Area, Aiken, South Carolina. EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

EG&G. 1983. A Catalogue of Vertical Aerial Imagery of the United States Department of Energy's Savannah River Plant and Surrounding Area, Aiken, South Carolina, Volume II. EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

ERDAS, Inc. 1995. ERDAS Imagine, Version 8.2. Atlanta, Georgia.

Esri, Inc. 1996. ArcInfo Version 7.0.4. Esri, Inc., Redlands, California.

Ezra, C. E. 1985. Steel Creek Land Cover Data Base Update, Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina Survey Dates: September 19, 1984 and April 25, 1985. EG&G/EM Letter Report DOE/ONS-8512, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Ezra, C. E. and L. R. Tinney, 1985a. Steel Creek Land Cover Data Base , Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina. EG&G/EM Letter Report DOE/ONS-8510, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Ezra, C. E. and L. R. Tinney. 1985b. Par Pond Macrophyte Study Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina. EG&G/EM Letter Report DOE (ONS-SRL)8513. EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Ezra, C. E., L. R. Tinney, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1986. Pen Branch and Four Mile Creek Land Cover Data Base, Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina. EG&G/EM, DOE (ONS-SRL)-8605. 54 pp.

Gladden, J. B., K. L. Brown, M. H. Smith, and A. Towns. 1985. "Distribution of Gamma Exposure Rates in a Reactor Effluent Stream Flood Plain System." Health Physics. 48:49-59.

Gladden, J. B., W. L. Specht, J. A. Bowers, N. V. Halverson, H. E. Mackey, Jr., and E. W. Wilde. 1989. Compliance of the Savannah River Plant L-Reactor Cooling System with Environmental Regulations-Demonstration in Accordance with Section 316(a) of the Clean Water Act, November 1985-December, 1987. DP-1766, Rev. 1. E. I. duPont de Nemours & Co., Inc. Savannah River laboratory, Aiken, South Carolina.

Jensen, J. R. and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1991a. "Remote Sensing of Freshwater Aquatic Macrophytes in Southeastern Lake: Part 1-Analysis of 30 Years of Vertical Aerial Photography." Proceedings 1991 ACSM-ASPRS Annual Convention, Volume 3, Remote Sensing, Baltimore, MD. pp.224-231.

Jensen, J. R., and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1991b. "Remote Sensing of Aquatic Macrophytes in a Southeastern Lake Using Aerial Photography, High Resolution Multispectral Scanner, and SPOT Data to Assess Seasonal Changes." Technical Papers, Amer. Soc. Photogrammetry, Baltimore. pp. 224-231.

Jensen, J. R., S. Narumalani, O. Weatherbee, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1991c. "Remote Sensing Offers an Alternative for Mapping Wetlands." Geo Info Systems. October, 1991. pp. 48-53.
 
Jensen, J. R., S. Narumalani, J. D. Althausan, J. W. Powell, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1993a. "Analysis of Stereoscopic Aerial Photography and High Resolution Multispectral Scanner Data to Document Historical Logging and Recent Management Practices on a Cypress-Tupelo Forest in South Carolina." Proceedings of Annual Meeting of American Society of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, New Orleans, LA. February 14-19, 1993. p.143.

Jensen, J. R., S. G. Burkhalter, J. D. Althausan, S. Narumalani, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1993b. "Integration of Historical Aerial Photography and a Geographic Information System to Evaluate the Impact of Human Activities in a Cypress-Tupelo Swamp." 14th Biennial Workshop on Color Photography and Videography in Resource Monitoring, Utah State University, May 25-28, 1993. pp. 125-134.

Jensen, J. R., D. J. Cowen, D. Graves, K. He, X. Huang, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1995. "An Image and Retrieval System Using Hypermedia Resources." Proceedings GIS/LIS '95 Annual Conference & Exposition, November 14-16, 1995, Nashville, TN Volume 1: 515-521 and page 512.

Jensen, J. R., D. Cowen, X. Huang, D. Graves, K. He, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1996. "Remote Sensing Image Browse and Archival Systems." Geocarto International, A Multidisciplinary Journal of Remote Sensing & GIS. 11(2):33-42.

Jobst, J. E. 1987. An Aerial Radiological Survey of the Savannah River Plant Drainage Basins, Date of Survey: August 1982. DOE/ONS-8312, Rev. 1. EG&G/EM, Las Vegas, Nevada.

Jobst, J. E. 1988. An Aerial Radiological Survey of the L Lake and Steel Creek, Savannah River Plant, Survey Date: August 1985. DOE(ONS-SRL)-8611. EG&G/EM, Las Vegas, Nevada.

Lloyd, F. T, R. M Fletcher, and N. J. Thompson. 1996. "Forestry Applications Put Historical Digital Orthoimagery to Use." Earth Observation Magazine, 5(1):33-35.

Mackey, H. E., Jr. 1993. "Application of Low Altitude Normal Color and False Color Infrared Photography for Delineation and Monitoring Wetland Restoration of a Large Carolina Bay." 14th Biennial Workshop on Color Photography and Videography in Resource Monitoring, Utah State University, May 25-28, 1993. p. 201.

Mackey, H. E. , Jr. 1994. "Roles of Historical Photography in Waste Site Characterization, Closure, and Remediation." Spectrum '94, August 14-18, 1994. Proceedings, Atlanta, GA. p. 1118.

McCort, W. D., L. C. Lee, and G. R. Wein. 1988. "Mitigating for Large-Scale Wetland Loss: A Realistic Endeavor?" In: J. A. Kusler, M. L. Quammen, and G. Brooks (eds.). Proceedings of the National Wetland Symposium: Mitigation of Impacts and Losses. Association of State Wetland Managers, Inc. pp. 359-367.

Meibaum, R. A. 1984a. Oblique Aerial Photographic Documentation of the Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina, Dates of Photographic Coverage: September 1982 Through April 1983. EG&G/EM Letter Report, DOE/ONS-8401, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Meibaum, R. A. 1984b. Vertical Aerial Photographic Documentation of the Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina, Dates of Photographic Surveys: August 1982 Through December 1983. EG&G/EM Letter Report, DOE/ONS-8405, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Meibaum, R. A. 1985a. Oblique Aerial Photographic Documentation of the Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina, Photographic Coverage for Calendar Year 1984. EG&G/EM Letter Report, DOE/ONS-8501, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV
 
Meibaum, R. A. 1985b. Vertical Aerial Photographic Documentation of the Savannah River Plant, Aiken, South Carolina, Photographic Coverage for Calendar Year 1984. EG&G/EM Letter Report, DOE/ONS-8502, EG&G Energy Measurements, Inc., Las Vegas, NV

Sharitz, R. R., J. W. Gibbons, and S. C. Gause. 1974a. "Impact of Production-Reactor Effluents on Vegetation in a Southeastern Swamp Forest." IN: J. W. Gibbons and R. R. Sharitz (eds.), Thermal Ecology, US Atomic Energy Commission, Symposium Series CONF-730505. pp. 356-362.

Sharitz, R. R., S. L. Scott, J. E. Pinder, III, and S. K. Woods. 1974b. "Uptake of Radiocesium from Contaminated Floodplain Sediment by Herbaceous Plants." Health Physics. 28:23-28.

Rea, T. E., D. J. Karapatakis, K. K. Guy, J. E. Pinder, III, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1996. "Bathometry as a Controlling Factor in Macrophyte Development: Thirty Years of Change Detection in a Former Reactor Cooling Pond." Proceedings of the American Society of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 1996 ASPRS/ACSM, Annual Convention & Exposition, Technical Papers, Volume 2, GIS & GPS, page 45, April 22-25, 1996, Baltimore, Maryland.

Rogers, V. A. 1990. Soil Survey of Savannah River Plant Area, Parts of Aiken, Barnwell, and Allendale Counties South Carolina. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service, 127 pp., 46 maps.

Stohr, C., W. J. Su, P. B. DuMontelle, and R. A. Griffin. 1987. Remote Sensing Investigations at a Hazardous-Waste Landfill. Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing. 53(11):1555-1563.

Stohr, C. and R. S. Lunetta. 1994. Special Issue on Remote Sensing in Solid and Hazardous Waste Management. Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing. 60(8):997.

Tinney, L. R., E. E. Ezra, and H. E. Mackey, Jr. 1986. Stream Corridor and Delta Wetlands Change Assessment, Savannah River Plant, Aiken, SC EG&G Letter Report, DOE (ONS-SRL) -8604. 55pp.

U.S. Geological Survey. 1964. 7.5 Minute Series (Topographic). Reston, VA.

Vision International, Inc. 1996. SoftPlotter User's Manual, Version 1.6. Earth city, Mo.

Wein, G. R. and W. D. McCort. 1988. "Sources of Complexity in Wetland Mitigation." In: J. Zelazny and J. S. Feierbend (eds.). Proceedings of Wetlands: Increasing Our Wetland Resources. Federation-Corporate Conservation Council. October 4-7, 1987. Washington, D. C. pp. 41-50.

Wein, G. R. and G. Pierce. 1995. "Case Study #1: L-Lake, Savannah River Plant, South Carolina." In: Native Plant Material Sources for Wetland Establishment: Freshwater Case Studies. Technical Report WRP-RE-5, U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, MS pp. 13-35.

Zeigler, C. C., I. B. Lawrimore, and W. E. O'Rear. 1985. Environmental Monitoring at the Savannah River Plant, Annual Report-1984. DPSPU 85-302. Health Protection Department, Savannah River Plant, E. I. duPont de Nemours and Company, Inc., Aiken, South Carolina.

 

AUTHOR INFORMATION


  Halkard E. Mackey, Jr.
Senior Research Scientist
Environmental & Geographic Information Systems
Integration Support Section
Westinghouse Savannah River Company
Aiken, SC 29808


telephone:  803-952-6898
fax number:  803-952-6849
e-mail address:  halkard.mackey@srs.gov